Hinh Dinh
580 California St., Suite 400
San Francisco, CA, 94104
Managing Natural Resources for Growth and Prosperity in Low Income Countries
2016, RePEc: Research Papers in Economics
Sign up for access to the world's latest research
checkGet notified about relevant papers
checkSave papers to use in your research
checkJoin the discussion with peers
checkTrack your impact
Abstract
This paper reviews the economic impact of natural resources on low-income countries and the policy options available to them as recommended by academia and international organizations. We find that traditional policy prescriptions are unrealistic and miss a number of issues that include what to do when resources are depleted, job creation for growth and prosperity, and heterogeneity in country conditions. The paper proposes to reconcile these problems by advocating a strategy based on new structural economics, with a special focus on economic growth and job creation using the proceeds of natural resources. This approach combines "learning by doing" with targeted public investment in order to develop infrastructure and human capital. For many low-income countries, development of simple, labor-intensive light manufacturing is the recommended path. This recommendation is elaborated in a case study of South Sudan, a poor, resource-rich country in Africa.
Related papers
EXPLORING THE ECONOMIC BENEFITS OF NATURAL RESOURCES IN THE THIRD WORLD ECONOMIES
Most of the economic problems confronting the third world and African economies have been tied to one inadequacy or the other such as: inadequate technology, lack of skilled manpower, institutional failure, political instability, underdeveloped markets, low capital formations, low savings etc. Africa as a continent is blessed with large chunk of natural resources ranging from mineral resources, wildlife, soil productivity, forestry, fishery, fresh water etc. Much of Africa’s natural resources are undiscovered or barely harnessed. Despite this abundance of natural resources claims suggest that many Western nations like the United States, Canada, France and the United Kingdom as well as emerging economic power houses like China often exploit Africa’s natural resources today . This pressure on Africa’s resources has led to wars and contributed to hijacking development Our aim therefore is to consider the relationship that exist between the exploration of natural resources and economic growth and development particularly in third world economies.
Africa's Natural Resource Wealth: A Paradox of Plenty and Poverty
Africa is blessed with vast natural resources and rich environments. It is generously endowed with productive land and with valuable natural resources, which include renewable resources (such as water, forestry, and fisheries) and non-renewable resources (minerals, coal, gas, and oil). Natural resources dominate many national economies and are central to the livelihoods of the poor rural majority. These resources are the basis of income and subsistence for large segments of Africa's population and constitute a principal source of public revenue and national wealth. Under the right circumstances, a natural resource boom can be an important catalyst for growth, development, and the transition from cottage industry to factory production. Indeed, with the right approach natural resources can be used to make the transformation from a low-value economy that relies on exports of primary commodities to one with a substantial labour-intensive manufacturing base. Ideally the development of these resources can be a blessing for the entire continent. But historically, those resources have often proved to be a curse than a blessing especially to the majority of the citizens in these African countries. It is commonly agreed that one of the avenues for getting many of the poorest African countries out of the low-income trap is to provide them with a big demand push that will generate enough demand complementarities to expand the size of markets and recover the fixed costs of industrialisation. Natural resource wealth could be used to pursue this goal. Unfortunately, in many African countries natural resource booms have only to a limited extent set off a dynamic growth process. This is largely due to failure to implement the right growth promotion policies and to ensure that strong institutions are in place, suggesting that it is very difficult to make the big push towards diversification and development of manufacturing in the resource-rich parts of Africa. The danger is that much of Africa is not industrialised and is stagnating in a staple trap, dependent on exports of a few mineral resources. In particular, oil resources and other point resource-dependency could, with the wrong policies, lead to this scenario. The failure of natural resource wealth to lead to the expected economic growth and development has been attributed to several factors, including the so-called "Dutch Disease", rent-seeking by elites, poor governance and weak institutions. The paper explores these causes of the resource curse and suggests ways to get out of the syndrome. 2
The role of natural resources in economic development. A review of theories and historical experiences
The paper analyses the different roles of NR in the development process, with particular focus on their connection with manufacturing, which is often seen as a preferred alternative. For the analysis, the term NR covers both agricultural and non-agricultural commodities. Both theoretical issues and historical experiences will be presented, so to help contextualising different views on the matter. Overall, there is still little theoretical agreement on the general appeal of a NR based development path, even though there are points of agreement between the two different strands of the literature.
Policies for Managing Natural Resources in Low Income Countries
2016
The literature on resource dependency in the last three decades is long on theoretical and empirical effects of natural resources on an economy, but short on practical policy prescriptions to deal with these effects. The recommended policies normally range from adjusting fiscal policy to deal with commodity volatility, adapting monetary policy to reduce the external shocks, and keeping the real exchange rate competitive. This paper makes the argument that these policies are targeted toward the symptoms of natural resource dependency, and not the underlying cause of concern about this dependency, which is, how to replace these resources when they are depleted. This point is all the more important considering that the poorest, resource dependent countries have negative genuine savings rate, i.e., they are living off their natural resource assets. Furthermore, traditional policies also miss another important feature of resource rich countries: the need to create jobs because the sector...
1 An Evolving Agenda on Natural Resource–Based Development in Africa
University of Toronto Press eBooks, 2022
Are natural resources an impetus for economic growth in Africa
UNITED NATIONS NATURAL RESOURCE FORUM JOURNAL, 2022
This study examines the effects of natural resource endowments on economic growth in Africa based on a sample of 37 African countries from 1996 to 2019. The sample is split into resource-rich and resource-poor
THE RESOURCE CURSE IN SUB-SAHARAN AFRICA: A REALITY CORROBORATED BY THE EMPIRICAL EVIDENCE
ESD Conference Proceedings
The abundance of natural resources is usually considered the blessing for the countries that own such resources. However, such wealth is often associated with poverty and a slower economic growth. This phenomenon is called the resource curse, and it shows that most countries that are rich in natural resources have markedly reduced economic growth and development, and it shows that the wealth of natural resources adversely affects their economies, although it is intuitively expected to be the opposite i.e. that such wealth would have a positive impact on the country's economic development. This paper, a product of the mentor-student joint effort, studies the paradox of natural resources and its most common channels through which it is converted from a blessing into a curse. The purpose of this study is to make conclusions about the existence of the natural resource curse, and to show the way or channel through which the wealth of natural resources becomes a blessing or a curse. The research was conducted in the countries where the largest part of exports in total merchandise exports were exports of natural resources, and such countries were selected from the region of Sub-Saharan Africa given that in this region natural resource curse is the most present. In the paper the export of natural resources is analyzed and compared with a GDP per capita of those countries, the dependence of these countries on the prices of resources is analyzed as well as diversity of their economies, the quality of institutions, and the presence of corruption. The data, which were used for analyzing, are statistical data collected by the World Bank, and the data from the other statistical sources related to such matters (BP and Transparency International).
Natural Resource Abundance: A Hidden Drag on Africa’s Development?
The Palgrave Handbook of African Political Economy, 2020
Africa has the world's richest concentration of minerals and gems under the ground, yet its resource-rich countries are also home to the poorest populations of the planet. 1 The Democratic Republic of Congo, for example, had untapped mineral deposits estimated at USD24 trillion in 2009 (Mining Africa 2018). While oil and precious mineral wealth is intuitively assumed to put the countries endowed with it at an economic advantage, many resource-rich countries in Africa are characterized instead by glaring poverty, slow economic growth and low levels of human capital as can be seen from their low human development index (Nkurunziza et al. 2017). Instead of bringing prosperity to the people these resources belong to, the wealth in oil and minerals in many African countries has often been accompanied by widespread poverty and poor socioeconomic development. Why has Africa failed to convert its generous wealth of natural resources into prosperity for its people? Various examples of dismal developmental outcomes associated with an abundance of natural resources can be found across Africa, from the environment destruction and violent conflicts caused by the exploitation of oil in the Niger Delta to the blood diamonds in Sierra Leone and Angola to and child labor in coltan mines in the eastern Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC). Dependence on natural resources has also been linked to violent conflicts and civil wars in various countries (
Natural Resources and the 'Quality' of Economic Development
Are natural resources a ‘blessing’ or a ‘curse’ for human development? This article attempts to answer the question by distinguishing between a ‘dependence’ on natural resources and an ‘abundance’ of the same. Dependence is measured in terms of exports of metals and fuel, while resource abundance is calculated on the basis of the subsoil assets per square kilometre and per capita. Results show the existence of a negative correlation between metals and ore exports and human development, while subsoil assets measures are, rather, positively related. These effects are particularly significant in countries with a comparatively lower institutional quality. The cases of Botswana, the Democratic Republic of Congo and Equatorial Guinea, briefly examined, suggest, however, that the effects of natural resources on human and economic development can be very different, and strictly related to specific national political and institutional characteristics.
Manufacturing Sector Performance and Natural Resources Endowment: Evidence from Natural Resource-rich Sub-Saharan African Countries
International Journal of Economics Development Research, 2021
Theoretically, it has been observed that an abundance of natural resources that are not well harnessed can displace some vital sectors of the economy, especially the manufacturing sector. In this study, using annual series ranging from 1990-2019 and under the framework of a Panel ARDL, we investigated the link between natural resources endowment and the performance of the manufacturing sector in natural resource-rich SSA countries. Findings of our study show that in the short-run, natural resources endowment has an insignificant positive link with the manufacturing sector performance. However, in the long-run, the contribution of natural resources to the performance of the manufacturing sector becomes negative. On grounds of these findings, we recommend, among others; the diversification of the economies of this group into manufacturing sector by using proceeds from the export of natural resources to develop infrastructure necessary to improve the sector.
Labour and employment creation with African resource development
Journal of Sustainable Development Law and Policy (The)
Natural resources are an assured source of government revenue, but this does not always translate into more jobs, better productivity or an increased demand for that country. Traditionally, the role of government in a resource-rich country has always been to act in the best interests of its citizens. In the case of natural resource-rich nations, this role also includes ensuring that jobs in the extractive sector are safe-both in the physical and financial sense. In such competitive environments, the private sector also has a fiduciary responsibility to ensure that all employees are fairly treated. However, it is evident that almost all African nations that are rich in resources are affected by lack of human development. This article examines the current state of affairs in the resource-rich African nations and their impact on human development. It focuses on how these resource-dependent economies are experiencing economic growth and why this growth does not directly translate into higher and better employment for the local populations. The article examines growth and human development from the perspectives of both the private-and public-sector actors. It recommends that private actors should have a complementary approach, through foreign direct investors or other modes, to the long-term policies and plans set out by the state. This approach would allow for successful intersectoral linkages and community development through higher job creation. It argues that the state is responsible for managing these natural resources and highlights the role of governance in this management. Governance issues, challenges, such as developmental gains, job creation, transparency and accountability are all addressed in the article. Finally, the article strongly recommends developing both human and institutional capital and regulating production.
Africa’s Natural Resources and Underdevelopment
Africa’s Natural Resources and Underdevelopment, 2017
The Development Effects of Natural Resources: A Geographical Dimension
SSRN Electronic Journal, 2011
Despite the recent growth resurgence, Sub-Saharan Africa (SSA) remains the poorest region in the world. At the same time, it is a region that heavily relies on natural resources. In this paper we investigate the extent to which the second fact helps explain the first one. The distinctive feature of our study is that we take a geographical perspective and allow the effect of natural resources to differ across regions of the world. Our findings suggest that (i) the effect of natural resource intensity on per-capita income is positive and significant in general, but almost negligible and possibly negative in SSA, (ii) natural resources have a negative effect on institutional quality in SSA only, (iii) natural resources hinder human capital accumulation in SSA much more than anywhere else, and (iv) the combination of bad disease environments and large resource endowments accounts for most of the observed cross-regional differences in the effect of natural resources.
Translating the extractive resources to economic growth and transformation
Journal of Sustainable Development Law and Policy (The)
Most African countries are heavily endowed with natural resources. This gives the continent both the potential for, and threat to, growth/development. Natural resources yield "rents," or profits from their production, which are crucial for resource-led development. The literature on the "rentier state" and how resource rents interact with institutions and political economy dynamics shows that rent flows through the socioeconomic system influence development outcomes. Although the natural resources sector provides significant opportunities for the near term, it also does have significant risks for future generations, and the costs and benefits of resource extraction are seldom borne equitably. Ensuring social equity is a major challenge in natural resource governance, generally falling to governments to referee trade-offs and protect the most vulnerable, including current and future generations. It is critical, therefore, for the continent to address itself to important policy questions to ensure that natural resources are a boon for Africa's sustainable growth
Natural resources, national income, and economic growth in Africa
World Development, 1995
Because standard measures of aggregate income such as gross domestic product (GDP) do not account for natural resource depletion, their use as gauges of economic performance tends to exaggerate the benefits of resource extraction. Accounting for natural resource depletion in 18 African countries indicates different patterns of growth than those suggested by GDP figures. Use of the revised measures in analyses of the link between exports and growth suggests that export expansion may generate increases in measured GDP without stimulating increased production. In contrast, real exchange rate alignment is correlated with growth in both conventional GDP and the revised accounts.
Natural Resources and Economic Development. Some lessons from History
In this work, we highlight the “lessons from history” that can be drawn from a historical discussion and understanding of the past and present of resource-rich developing economies to obtain conditions for successful natural resources-based development. The conceptual core of our answer to those questions will be based on three key ideas. First, abundance of natural resources is closely associated with levels of economic development. Second, we emphasize that an abundance of natural resources is not a fixed situation. It is a process that reacts to changes in the structure of commodity prices and factor endowments, and progress requires capital, labour, technical change and appropriate institutional arrangements. Finally, history shows that institutional quality is the key factor to deal with abundant natural resources and, especially, with the rents derived from their use and exploitation. The ways in which natural resources interact with economic development are mediated by the performance of institutional arrangements in at least three dimensions: (i) institutions’ ability to limit rent-seeking opportunities that divert innovation and resources from productive avenues; (ii) political competition and participation relate to rules governing chief executive recruitment and selection, the fairness and impartiality of electoral processes, and constraints on executive power; and (iii) the characteristics of institutions that reduce transactional risk through proper enforcement of property rights. In sum, history is very clear in showing that natural capital is non-neutral for economic performance but it is a systemic component of economic development where institutional quality is the key component to deal with and create “curses” and “blessings” of natural resources.
The Challenges of Developing Eastern Africa's Natural Resources
The discovery of significant oil and gas reserves in Eastern Africa provides a major opportunity for boosting economic development in the region. In developing these reserves, Kenya, Mozambique, Tanzania and Uganda have the chance to rapidly transform their economies and address development needs. However, this opportunity comes with risks and policy challenges, and dependency on natural resources for economic growth has been frequently linked to poor macroeconomic performance in developing countries.
Mainstreaming Mineral Wealth in Growth and Poverty Reduction Strategies
Minerals & Energy - Raw Materials Report, 2006
Many studies claim that mineral resources impact negatively on economic growth particularly in developing countries. This paper briefly reviews this argument (the natural resources curse hypothesis) and subjects it to examination. The paper argues that poor performance is not an inherent characteristic of minerals-driven economies. It considers mineral endowments a capital that can spur growth and reduce poverty in developing countries if deployed under appropriate conditions. The paper identifies the benefit streams of mining and the challenges for their equitable creation, investment, distribution and management. It articulates the conditions, success factors and strategies to maximizing the contribution of the minerals sector to growth and development in Africa. They hinge on creating a conducive and competitive policy, legal and regulatory environment and framework for business development; improving governance and management systems anchored on strong and capable institutions; opening up opportunities, sharpening investment decisions; promoting linkages between the minerals sector and other sectors of the economy; empowering communities, establishing coalitions of change, and facilitating knowledge and competencies creation.
Related topics
Loading Preview
Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.