Academia.eduAcademia.edu

THE «CRUSADE» OF THE EXCOMMUNICATE VOIVODE: THOMAS SZÉCSÉNYI IN FALL 1330

Profile image of Alexandru SimonAlexandru Simon

2024, Acta Terrae Septemcastrensis

https://doi.org/10.2478/ACTATR-2024-0004
visibility

…

description

10 pages

link

1 file

Abstract

On 10 January 1331, Pope John XXII demanded from Andrew Szécsi, bishop of Transylvania, and the cousin of Denis, former ban of Severin, not to publicize the excommunication of the voivode of Transylvania, Thomas Szécsényi. The pope acted at King Charles-Robert of Anjou's request, who had urged him to forgive the voivode and convinced him-after the excommunication-that the voivode had acted in the king's rightful interest. John XXII did not say anything about the reasons that had led to Szécsényi's excommunication, although he mentioned that this was not the first time that Szécsényi had been excommunicated by Szécsi. On 6 January 1331, Pope John XXII, at Thomas' demand, had already granted the voivode a full remission of his sins in the eventuality of his death, provided that the voivode would not commit his previous crimes. "In both Papal registers in which the remission was preserved, it was entered after the message sent by the pope to Bishop Szécsi. We can only speculate as to the reasons of the "delay". John XXII was not exactly completely open towards his Hungarian correspondents. Additionally, Charles-Robert had just returned from a disastrous campaign in Wallachia. Furthermore, Transylvania already had its fair share of "private conflicts".

Related papers

To eradicate the depravity of heresy: a Hungarian crusade in the early thirteenth century? In: Merceneries and Crusaders. Ed. Attila Bárány. Debrecen, 2024. 87-104.
Gábor Barabás

This paper is a short contribution to the history of the crusades led against so-called heretics in the first half of the thirteenth century. The topic is well known in the Western historical research, as well as in the popular culture, due to the significance of the campaigns in Southern France against the Cathars, also known as the Albigensian Crusade, in the early thirteenth century. Nonetheless, the idea of a crusade to exterminate the depravity of heresy emerged in relation to other territories and local groups as well. The relationship between the Kingdom of Hungary and its southern neighbour, Bosnia offers a quite similar example, as accusations of heterodoxy played an important role in the efforts of the Hungarian rulers to assert their overlordship over the territories of Bosnia. The issue appeared as early as the outset of the thirteenth century, when accusations emerged against the Bosnian ruler, Ban Kulin claiming that he and his subjects were no true Christians. Although the monarch was able to acquit himself from the accusations due to the examination ordered by Pope Innocent III (1198–1216), there were no military actions in order at that time, yet the controversy regarding the state of Christianity in Bosnia persisted. This study investigates the situation in the 1220s and 1230s when the idea of crusaders fighting for the cause to abolish heresy arose several times, and it seems possible that a Hungarian royal prince, Duke Coloman of Slavonia, even lead his armies – as a crusader – to Bosnia. The events of the campaign(s) are scarcely known; however, the preparations are tangible in the main source material, the pontifical correspondence. Therefore I will analyse the efforts made by Honorius III (1216–1227) and Gregory IX (1227–1241) in this matter, revealing the role of crusader terminology. It is quite intriguing that Hungarian sources contain only indirect information regarding the crusade against Bosnian heresy, even though the notion of fighting infidels as crusaders a few years after the crusade of King Andrew II (1205–1235) must have been widely known among members of the lay and ecclesiastical elite of the Realm of St Stephen.

View PDFchevron_right
The Catholic Church in Poland and King Władysław III's Crusade Against the Turks, in: Holy War in Late Medieval and Early Modern East-Central Europe, red. J. Smołucha, J. Jefferson, A. Wadas, Kraków 2017, pp. 95-107.
Tomasz Graff
View PDFchevron_right
Popes, Rulers and their Delegates: Chapters of Papal–Hungarian Relations in the Thirteenth Century. Pécs, 2023. Thesaurus Historiae Ecclesiasticae in Universitate Quinqueecclesiensi 13.
Gábor Barabás

In the past decade the focus of the author’s research has been on various aspects of the relations of the Hungarian Kingdom with the Papacy in the thirteenth century. Among other things the following topics have been dealt with: the activities of papal legates sent to the Realm of St Stephen, the operation of papal delegated jurisdiction in the church of Hungary, and the role that certain members of the royal family played in this era All but one of the studies presented in this book have already been published. Nevertheless, the papers are updated based on comments received since their original publications. The texts of several studies were altered, new parts were added, certain passages were removed, and the references were completed with recent, or previously missing works. Hopefully, this collection – of somewhat overlapping studies – off ers new aspects on the research of the history of the Papacy and the Kingdom of Hungary in the High Middle Ages.

View PDFchevron_right
Robert-Marius Mihalache - The Holy See’s Intervention in the Struggle for the Occupation of the Hungarian Throne (1290–1310), in Transylvanian Review, vol. XX, Supplement No. 2:1, 2011, p. 155-164.
Robert-Marius Mihalache
View PDFchevron_right
The Greek Rite Transylvanian Church in the 1450: Archbishop John of Caffa and the Crusade in East-Central Europe
Iulian Mihai Damian

Mélanges d’Histoire Générale, NS, I/2 (= Extincta est lucerna orbis: John Hunyadi and his time, edited by Ana Dumitran, Loránd Mádly, Alexandru Simon), Cluj-Napoca, Academia Romana: Centrul de Studii Transilvane – IDC Press, ISBN 978-973-1856-01-8, p. 149-160, 2009

The present article discuss the presence in Transylvania of one of the fist Greek rite bishops here attested, known as John of Caffa, bringing to light new evidences of his life, position and further carrier.

View PDFchevron_right
Historiographic Controversy about the Crusades against Bosnian "Heretics"
Journal of Balkan and Black Sea Studies

Journal of Balkan and Black Sea Studies, 2020

View PDFchevron_right
Negotiating Interfaith Relations in Eastern Christendom: Pope Gregory IX, Bela IV of Hungary, and the Latin Empire
Michael Lower
View PDFchevron_right
MOLDAVIA, MOSCOW AND THE CRUSADE OF POPE ALEXANDER VI: THE EMBASSY OF SIGISMUND ZANTHAI (1502), Medieval And Early Modern Studies for Central and Eastern Europe, V (2013)
liviu pilat
View PDFchevron_right
Heretics, Pirates, and Legates. The Bosnian Heresy, the Hungarian Kingdom, and the Popes in the Early 13th Century. Specimina Nova Pars Prima Sectio Mediaevalis IX. (2017) 35-58.
Gábor Barabás

The study examines a special aspect of the relations between the Papacy and the Hungarian Kingdom in the first half of the 13th century: the fight against the heretics of Bosnia, or the Bosnian Church. The question of this heresy is not investigated from a dogmatic, or a legal point of view; the analysis focuses on the measures taken by the Papacy and the Hungarian Kingdom. Pontifical legates were entrusted with tasks concerning heresy and piracy in Bosnia and Dalmatia since the very beginning of the century, while the Hungarian rulers and several prelates also took part in the struggle. My presentation starts with the investigation against Ban Kulin of Bosnia led by the papal chaplain John of Casamari, whereas among other topics the problem of the Dalmatian pirates, the Bosnian campaign of Duke Coloman of Slavonia and the integration of the diocese of Bosnia into the Hungarian Church are analysed too.

View PDFchevron_right
The Papacy’s Policy on Hungarian Court Personnel 1523–1526: the Case of Imre Kálnai’s Appointments as Archdeacon and Royal Secretary. In: Infima aetas Pannonica. Studies in Late Medieval Hungarian History. Eds. Péter E. Kovács–Kornél Szovák. Budapest, Corvina, 2009, 163–193.
Bálint Lakatos
View PDFchevron_right

References (55)

  1. Kersken 2018, IX-XXIV; Lucherini 2015: 58-72. The chronicle ended with Louis' enthronement in the summer 1342 and did not deal with any of the subsequent events.
  2. Wertner 1893: 119-134, Kovács 2005: 78-85.
  3. 3 Zsoldos 2011, 311-313; Farkas 2022: 18-45, at 23-28.
  4. Bagi 2021: 131-143.
  5. Schmitt-Ursprung 2021, 9-218 (at 61-72), and 269-326 (at 286-292).
  6. Cazacu-Mureșan 2013. See also Pippidi 2008: 5-20, at 17-18.
  7. See also Bonfini 1936, 201-202; Thuróczy 1985, 113-114; Michael 1997, 278.
  8. 9 The idea predates in fact World War I (e.g. Hașdeu 1893, CLXXXII).
  9. Constantinescu 1984, 145.
  10. Pascu et alii 1977, no. 9, p. 20, nos. 21-22, pp. 44-47.
  11. Simon 2014: 59-76; Piti 2016: 381-392, at 384 (note 25);
  12. The problem can also be ascribed to the immediate post-Trianon context (e.g. Minea 1925: 404-405 and 410).
  13. E.g. Jamme 2014, 279-341
  14. Simon 2023: 30-72.
  15. Pascu 1945, here at 24-25. The text read (in both editions): […] Regele ungar voia să pedepsească pe Toma, dar voevodul, aşteptându-se la aceasta, ia măsurile necesare, cerând intervenţia papei. Papa, la rândul său, scrie episcopului Transilvaniei să intervină în favoarea lui Toma, să-l împace cu regele, iar regelui îi scrie să-l ierte pe voevod 72 . Că aceste fapte erau consecinţele războiului, reiese clar: războiul se sfârşise în luna Noemvrie a anului 1330, iar voevodul trebuia să scrie papei în aceiaşi lună sau în cea următoare, pentruca răspunsul să fie 31 A conflict usually neglected in Hungarian historiography (e.g. Varga 2003, 215-226).
  16. E.g. Popa-Gorjanu 2006, 143-177.
  17. See, under the circumstances, the deed issued by Charles-Robert for the royal city of Cluj on 10 July 1331, following his explicitly mentioned transalpine campaign and the interferences of voivode Thomas Szécsényi (Jakab 1870, pp. 41-42; AOkl., XV, no. 267, p. 152).
  18. Pascu et alii 1977, no. 36, pp. 66-67.
  19. For a more positive image: Zsoldos 2017, 188-192.
  20. We could thus speculate that Szécsényi was excommunicated after entering Wallachia. Caution is gravely advised.
  21. Lucherini 2015, 109-110. The Romanian edition abruptly and wrongfully ends with the so- called battle of Posada. Bibliography
  22. Almasi,-Kőfalvi 2004, AOkl., XIV. 1330, eds. Tibor Almasi, Tamás Kőfalvi (Budapest -Szeged, 2004), no. 613.
  23. Bagi 2021, Dániel Bagi, "Záh Felicián ügye Mügelni Henrik német nyelvű krónikájában", Pontes, 4 (2021): 131-143.
  24. Bonfini 1936, Antonio Bonfini, Rerum Ungaricarum decades, eds. József Fogel, Béla Iványi, László Juhász, II (Budapest, 1936).
  25. Borghi 2017, Beatrice Borghi, "Bologne et le cardinal legat Bertrand Du Pouget. Le refus d'un grand projet," Journal of Mediae AEtatis Sodalicium,15 (2017). Farkas 2022, Csaba Farkas, "Család és politika az Anjou-korban: Lackfiak és Szécsiek (1308-1359)," Belvedere Meridionale, 34, no. 4 (2022).
  26. Casteen 2015, Elizabeth Casteen, From She-Wolf to Martyr: The Reign and Disputed Reputation of Johanna I of Naples (Ithaca, NY -London, 2015).
  27. Cazacu-Mureșan 2013, Matei Cazacu, Dan Ioan Mureşan, Ioan Basarab, un domn român la începuturile Ţării Româneşti (Kishinev, 2013).
  28. Constantinescu 1984, Nicolae Constantinescu, Curtea de Argeş. 1200-1400. Asupra începuturilor Ţării Româneşti (Bucharest, 1984).
  29. Eszterházy 1866, János Eszterházy, "András erdélyi püspök felségsértése 1349-ben," Századok, 2, no. 2 (1868): 90-94.
  30. Jamme 2014, Armand Jamme, "Des usages de la démocratie. Deditio et contrôle politique des cités lombardes dans le grand projet de Jean XXII," in Papst Johannes XXII. Konzepte und Verfahren seines Pontifikats, eds. Martin Rohde, Hans-Joachim Schmidt (Berlin, 2014).
  31. Jakab 1870, Elek Jakab, Oklevéltár Kolozsvár története első kötetéhez, I (Buda, 1870). Hașdeu 1893, Bogdan Petriceicu Haşdeu, Etymologicum Magnum Romaniae. Dicționarul limbei istorice și poporane a românilor, [as introduction to] IV. Negru Vodă. Un secol şi jumătate din începuturile Statului Ţerei Românesci (1230-1380) (Bucharest,1893), CLXXXII.
  32. Hegi 2019, Géza Hegi, "Az erdélyi káptalan Árpád-és Anjou-kori archontológiája (1199-1387)," Turul, 92, no. 2 (2019).
  33. Kelly 2003, Samantha Kelly, The New Solomon: Robert of Naples (1309-1343) and Fourteenth Century Kingship (=The Medieval Mediterranean, XLVIII) (Leiden -Boston -Cologne, 2003).
  34. Kersken 2018, Norbert Kersken, "The Chronicle of the Deeds of the Hungarians in European Context," in The Illuminated Chronicle (Chronica de gestis Hungarorum e codice picto saec. xiv.) (=Central European Medieval Texts, 9), eds. János M. Bak, László Veszprémy (Budapest -New York, 2018), IX-XXIV.
  35. Krekić 1952, Bariša Krekić, "Courier Traffic between Dubrovnik, Constantinople and Thessalonika in the First Half of the Fourteenth Century," Zbornik Radova Vizantološkog Instituta, 1 (1952).
  36. Kovács 2005, András W. Kovács, "Szécsényi Tamás erdélyi vajda familiárisairól," Erdélyi Múzeum, 67, nos. 3-4 (2005): 78-85.
  37. Lucherini 2015, Vinni Lucherini, "Il Chronicon pictum ungherese (1358): racconto e immagini al servizio della costruzione dell'identità nazionale," Rivista di Stori della Miniatura, 19 (2015): 58-72.
  38. Michael 1997, The Annals of Jan Długosz, ed. Maurice Michael (Chichester, 1997). Minea 1925, Ilie Minea, "Marino Sanudo bătrânul despre noi," and Idem, "Ziua morţii lui Nicolae Alexandru Voievod," Cercetări Istorice, 1 (1925).
  39. Pascu 1945, Ştefan Pascu, "Contribuţiuni documentare la istoria românilor în sec. XIII şi XIV," Anuarul Institutului de Istorie Naţională din Cluj, 10 (1945): 149-220, at 168-169 (first published as booklet: Contribuţiuni documentare la istoria românilor în sec. XIII şi XIV (=Biblioteca Institutului de Istorie Naţională, 19) (Sibiu, 1944).
  40. Pascu et alii 1977, Documenta Romaniae Historica (DRH), D. Relaţiile între Ţările Române, I. 1222-1456, eds. Ştefan Pascu, Constantin Cihodaru, Konrad G. Gündisch, Damaschin Mioc, Viorica Pervain (Bucharest, 1977).
  41. Pécout-Mathieu 2024, Un Moyen Age en partage, eds. Thierry Pécout, Isabelle Mathieu (Rennes, 2024).
  42. Pippidi 2008, Andrei Pippidi, "La originile Ţării Româneşti," Revista Istorică, NS, 19, nos. 1-2 (2008).
  43. Piti 2016, Ferenc Piti, "Királyi hadoszlások Károly Róbert uralkodása idején," Hadtörténelmi Közlemények, 129, no. 2 (2016).
  44. Popa-Lisseanu 1937, Chronicon pictum Vindobonense (=Fontes Historiae Daco- Romanorum, XI), ed. Gheorghe Popa-Lisseanu (Bucharest, 1937).
  45. Popa-Gorjanu 2006, Cosmin Popa-Gorjanu, "Conflict şi memorie în Transilvania secolelor XIII-XIV: Episcopia Transilvaniei şi Gyan fiul lui Alard," in Secolul al XIII-lea pe meleagurile locuite de români, ed. Adrian A. Rusu (Cluj-Napoca, 2006).
  46. Sălăgean 2007, Tudor Sălăgean, Un voievod al Transilvaniei: Ladislau Kán (1294- 1315) (Cluj-Napoca, 2007).
  47. Schmitt-Ursprung 2021, Oliver Jens Schmitt, "Der Balkan zwischen regionaler Herrschaftsbildung und osmanischer Eroberung (ca. 1300-ca. 1500)," and Daniel Ursprung, "Die Walachei vom 14. bis zum Beginn des 17. Jahrhunderts," in Handbuch zur Geschichte Südosteuropas, eds. Ulf Brunnbauer, Konrad Clewing, O.J. Schmitt, II. Herrschaft und Politik in Südosteuropa von 1300 bis 1800, ed. O.J. Schmitt (Berlin -Boston, 2021). Simon 2014, Alexandru Simon, "Principele Dominic, secuii şi Ţara de Jos a Moldovei," Anuarul Institutului de Istorie A.D. Xenopol, 51, suppl. (2014) [2015].
  48. Simon 2023, Alexandru Simon, "Dacia at Posada: Marino Sanudo Torsello's Letter to Cardinal Bertrand du Pouget (April 10, 1330)," Revista Arhivelor, 96, nos. 1-4 (2019) [2023]: 30-72.
  49. Tăutu 1962, Acta Ioannis PP. XXII (1317-1334) (=Fontes, III, 7-2), ed. Aloisie L. Tăutu (Rome, 1962), nos. 92-a.
  50. Temesváry 1922, János Temesváry, Erdély középkori püspökei (Kolozsvár, 1922). Thuróczy 1985, John Thuróczy, Chronica Hungarorum, I. Textus, eds. Erzsébet Galántai, Gyula Kristó (Budapest, 1985).
  51. Varga 2003, Tibor Róbert Varga, "Ádatok a 14. századi szentszéki bíráskodásra Erdélyben," in Tanulmányok a középkorról, III, ed. Boglárka Weisz (Szeged, 2003).
  52. Wertner 1893, Mór Wertner, "Szécsényi Tamás erdélyi vajda (1299-1354)," Erdélyi Múzeum, 10, no. 3 (1893).
  53. Zimmermann-Werner 1892, Urkundenbuch zur Geschichte der Deutschen in Siebenbürgen, I. 1198-1341, eds. Franz Zimmermann, Carl Werner (Hermannstadt, 1892), no. 492.
  54. Zsoldos 2011, Attila Zsoldos, Magyarország világi archontológiája. 1000-1301 (Budapest, 2011).
  55. Zsoldos 2017, Attila Zsoldos, A Druget-tartomány története. 1315-1342 (Budapest, 2017).

Related papers

Franciscans or Jesuits: Attempts to Resurrect Catholicism in Transylvania (1589–1592)
Tamás Kruppa

Incorrupta monumenta ecclesiam defendunt. Studi odderti a mons. Sergio Pagano, prefetto dell’Archivio Segreto Vaticano I/2, a cura di Andreas Gottsmann – Pierantonio Piatti – Andreas E. Rehberg, Cittá del Vaticano, 2018, 889–903.

View PDFchevron_right
The Renaissance Papacy and Catholicization of the 'Manichean Heretics': Rethinking the 1459 Purge of the Bosnian Kingdom
Luka Špoljarić

Global Reformations: Transforming Early Modern Religions, Societies, and Cultures (ed. Nicholas Terpstra), 2019

View PDFchevron_right
King Matthias Corvinus and the Papacy in Early 1472: Miklós Nyújtódi Székely in Rome
Antonín Kalous

Povijesni prilozi / Historical Contributions, 2017

View PDFchevron_right
The Papacy and the Czech Lands between Reform and Reformation (1417-1526)
Antonín Kalous
View PDFchevron_right
The Popes and the Baltic Crusades 1147-1254
Iben Fonnesberg-Schmidt

2006

View PDFchevron_right
Papal crusade propaganda and attacks against Jews in France in the 1230s: a breakdown of communication
Christoph T Maier

Journal of Medieval History, 2023

View PDFchevron_right
J. Smołucha, East-Central Europe and the Idea of Crusade in the Second Half of the Fifteenth Century [in:] Holy War, eds. J. Smołucha, J. Jefferson, A. Wadas, Kraków, 2017, pp. 109-122
Janusz Smołucha
View PDFchevron_right
Popes, prelates, pretenders : the role of the high clergy of Croatia, Dalmatia and Slavonia in the fight for the Hungarian throne in the Fourteenth century
Mišo Petrović

MA thesis, 2015

View PDFchevron_right
John Szapolyai and the cities of Transylvania
Emőke Gálfi

A Forgotten Hungarian Royal Dynasty: the Szapolyais

View PDFchevron_right
Nos tuis supplicationibus inclinati: Pope Innocent IV and the Decline of Delegated Jurisdiction in Hungary in the Mid-13th Century. Povijesni Prilozi vol 39. nr. 59 (2020), 7-29.
Gábor Barabás
View PDFchevron_right
Excommunication under discussion in the early twelfth century diocese of Liège: A comparative inquiry into the opinions of Lambert of St.-Hubert and Sigebert of Gembloux.
Ortwin Huysmans

2014

View PDFchevron_right
NEW DETAILS REGARDING THE EXPULSION OF BISHOP GYULA GLATTFELDER FROM ROMANIA
Szabolcs András
View PDFchevron_right
“L'Euesque en soit adverty”. Excommunication in the Exile Congregations
Andrew Spicer
View PDFchevron_right
The crusades against the Hussites in Bohemia (1419–1436)
Alexandra Kaar

The Crusades Against the Hussites in Bohemia (1419–1436), in: Crusading Against Christians in the Middle Ages, ed. Mike Carr, Nikolaos Chrissis and Gianluca Raccagni , 2024

View PDFchevron_right
ON THE ATTACK OF THE HUNGARIAN KING BELA III ON SERBIA IN LIGHT OF THE LETTER OF EMPEROR ISAAC II TO POPE CELESTINE III
Ivana Komatina
View PDFchevron_right
The role of the Franciscans in the kingdom of Bosnia during the rein of King Stjepan Tomaš (1443-1461)
Paweł Cholewicki

CEU Annual of Medieval Studies, 2019

View PDFchevron_right
The Hungarian Royal Family and the Delegated Papal Jurisdiction from the Mongol Invasion to the late Thirteenth Century. Specimina Nova Pars Prima Sectio Mediaevalis XII (2023), 87-100.
Gábor Barabás
View PDFchevron_right
Hungary and the Second Crusade
Zsolt Hunyadi
View PDFchevron_right
Pius II and the Andreis (1462): textual circulation, crusade promotion and papal power
Barry Torch, Jennifer Mara DeSilva

Renaissance Studies, 2022

View PDFchevron_right
John of Wildeshausen OP († 1252) — a bishop on the Hungarian periphery in the thirties of the 13th century in the light of contemporary Dominican and Church legislation
Gabriel Peter Hunčaga

Przegląd Historyczny , 2021

View PDFchevron_right
'The Sins of the Sons of Man': A New Letter of Pope Celestine III Concerning the 1195 Crusade of Alarcos.
Kyle C Lincoln, Miguel Gomez
View PDFchevron_right
The Teutonic Knights’ Military Confrontation with the Cumans during their Stay in Transylvania (1211–1225)
Roman Hautala
View PDFchevron_right
The Official Papal Policy towards Bohemia and Moravia in the 1460s and Its Relation to the Penitentiary Office: the Case of Olomouc.
Antonín Kalous
View PDFchevron_right
From the ‘Italic League’ to the ‘Italic Crusade’: Crusading under Renaissance Popes Nicholas V and Pius II
Iulian Mihai Damian

Italy and Europe’s Eastern Border. 1204-1669, ed. I. M. Damian – I. A. Pop - M. Popovic - Al. Simon, Frankfurt am Main: Peter Lang Verlag, p. 79-94, 2012

View PDFchevron_right
Venice, the Papacy, and the Crusades before 1204
Thomas F Madden

The Medieval Crusade, 2004

View PDFchevron_right

Related topics

Medieval HungaryHistory of Transylvania
580 California St., Suite 400
San Francisco, CA, 94104